Elevated view of low-rise commercial buildings, landscaped parking and autumn trees along a suburban Athens retail corridor.

What the Georgia Square Mall Overlay Means for Atlanta Highway

The draft Mall Area Special District Overlay includes this clause.

"A demolition permit shall not be issued if the proposed demolition would result in the reduction of leasable commercial space within the Mall Area Special District Overlay below the 150,000 square feet, unless permits have also been issued for replacement commercial space sufficient to restore or maintain the required minimum square footage upon completion."

That clause appears in the Athens-Clarke County staff report dated October 1, 2026. It requires the overlay area to hold at least 150,000 square feet of leasable commercial space "at all times." The mall it would govern is about 800,000 square feet across two stories. So the floor protects less than a fifth of the commercial space standing on the site today.

The developer is no longer seeking the tax-allocation financing that once gave the county a contract with build-order terms.

Why the County's Leverage Moved Into the Zoning Text

The 2023 arrangement gave Athens-Clarke County a contract. The Mayor and Commission adopted Planned Development PD-2021-12-3752 in early 2023 for a mixed residential, commercial and office project. A Development Agreement followed, with terms covering the order of construction and how it would be financed. That agreement expired in early 2026.

As Flagpole reported in March 2023, that plan called for roughly 1,000 apartments, 200 townhouses and 70,000 square feet of new commercial space. Two mall wings would come down, and the central area and Belk would stay. In return, the county offered future property tax revenue through the Mall Area Tax Allocation District, which Flagpole's July 2026 account put at $186 million. The total project was valued at about $660 million.

The structure of that money is why the plan stalled. According to Flagpole's January 2026 report, the TAD only reimbursed the developer for costs already spent. County attorneys set it up that way to protect taxpayers. Mark Jennings of The Leaven Group said the setup gave him no collateral to offer lenders. Leaven's attorney, M. John Constantino, then told county officials there was "no viable financing path" to begin construction. Mayor Kelly Girtz told the paper that "maybe it would've worked in 2018," before the tighter lending, higher interest rates and higher construction costs that followed COVID.

By July, Jennings had ended the public-private partnership. "The Universal Studios/Disneyworld/Carnival Cruise plan we had doesn't work without $186 million," he said at a July 23 town hall, as Flagpole reported. The TAD still exists. "The bucket's not going away. We're just not asking to access it anymore," said Jon Williams, president and CEO of W&A Engineering, the Athens firm designing the project. Flagpole noted that the county could still use the TAD for infrastructure around the mall later.

Once the reimbursement contract was gone, the community-benefits package went with it. Girtz said the county would still shape what comes next through the overlay. That is why the overlay's commercial terms carry so much weight.

The Draft Overlay Next to the 2023 Plan

The overlay was drafted at the direction of a Mayor and Commission resolution passed March 3, 2026. Athens-Clarke County itself is the applicant, and Leaven Group LLC owns the property. The draft would remove the planned development and set standards for 79.4 acres, which covers the mall, four outparcels on Atlanta Highway and the former movie theater site behind the mall.

Term 2023 Planned Development Draft overlay, Oct. 1, 2026 staff report
How it is built Binding site plan, built exactly as drawn and in a set order Phased over time, guided by standards
Residential density About 1,000 apartments and 200 townhouses 50 bedrooms per acre by right, up to 75 through Inclusionary Zoning
Height 65 feet under C-G zoning Up to 100 feet, 45 feet within 250 feet of adjacent residential property
Commercial space About 70,000 sq ft new, plus retained center and Belk At least 150,000 sq ft leasable at all times
Public financing TAD reimbursement of eligible infrastructure costs None sought
Transit Bus station among community benefits 2-acre minimum Athens Transit site

The density change is large. Standard C-G zoning allows 25 bedrooms per acre. Flagpole estimated the overlay could allow about 4,000 bedrooms across the property. Ground-floor homes would be allowed anywhere except within 250 feet of the Atlanta Highway right-of-way. Townhome groups could run up to eight units. The staff report lists the proposed use as multifamily.

Planning Director Bruce Lonnee explained the reason for the flexibility to Flagpole: "If downtown Athens had to be built in one single moment, I don't think anybody could do it." Phasing fixes the financing problem that sank the 2023 plan. It also means a 150,000-square-foot floor matters less than the question of when that space has to exist.

The Planning Commission Is Writing the Build Order

The Planning Commission tabled the overlay on August 6 and again on September 3, asking staff to define a core urban center and to work with the owner on the parts of the site that can't be built on. At the October 1 meeting, according to the minutes, commissioners said the overlay "could allow for too many residential uses and not a mix." When they asked Williams whether the developer objected to commercial requirements, the minutes record that the developer "was open to ideas but resistant to requirements."

Commissioners then edited the draft as a committee of the whole. One of their instructions to staff was to establish "a commercial threshold that unlocks residential development." The October 1 draft has no such threshold. Its 150,000-square-foot floor only limits demolition. A threshold of the kind commissioners requested would work as a build-order rule, with a set amount of commercial space coming first and housing approvals following it. They also asked for enforceable metrics, better connectivity and a definition of "drive-through facility" in place of "quick serve restaurants." They voted unanimously to postpone the item to the November Planning Commission meeting. The overlay was on the November 5 Planning Commission agenda. After the Planning Commission, it goes to the Mayor and Commission for a final vote, according to the Athens Banner-Herald.

The developer has also said its plan waits on the zoning. "I'm not going to spend one penny until I get my zoning approved," Jennings told a crowd of about 300 in July.

Overlay Details and Commission Discussions

The October 1 draft and commissioners' discussions covered four topics.

  1. Whether a commercial threshold was added. The October 1 draft's floor only stops demolition. That protects existing space and leaves the timing of new commercial space open. A threshold that has to be met before residential development proceeds, which commissioners asked staff to write, would put new retail and service space into the early phases.
  2. The 250-foot frontage band. The draft would allow ground-floor homes anywhere except within 250 feet of the Atlanta Highway right-of-way.
  3. The transit site. The October 1 draft calls for the county to accept the 2-acre Athens Transit site before any certificate of occupancy is issued for the first phase built under the overlay. Today the property has two bus stops serving Routes 20 and 21. Where the transfer facility goes will shape foot traffic inside the overlay.
  4. Parking and unit caps. The draft limits multifamily dwellings to two full baths and a maximum of two and one-half parking spaces per dwelling. Those caps steer the residential mix and the parking supply that any new commercial space would share.

The current tenant base sets the baseline. Belk is the mall's only remaining anchor. Macy's closed in 2017, Sears in 2019 and JCPenney in 2020. A floor of 150,000 square feet would cover a Belk-anchored center plus a modest ring of inline and pad space, which is a long way from a regional mall. Flagpole has also noted that, without TAD money, the next plan may look more like Jennings' 2020 concept of more than 1,000 apartments spread around the parking lot. That version was widely criticized as too car-centric.

This is general market commentary and not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm zoning terms and any deal-specific questions with your attorney, lender or the Athens-Clarke Planning Department. For context on how student and employment growth feed demand across the market, see our look at how university growth shapes Athens commercial demand and our Athens vs. Watkinsville retail corridor comparison.

FAQ

Is the Georgia Square TAD gone? No. Leaven Group stopped seeking reimbursement from it, and Flagpole reported that the county could still use it for infrastructure near the mall.

Is there a site plan for the redevelopment? Not yet. The staff report says no specific development proposal comes with the overlay, and Jennings has said a plan will follow the zoning approval.

Does the proposed overlay change the Future Land Use map? No. The underlying C-G zoning stays consistent with the General Business designation.

Ashley Goodroe can prepare a valuation. Request a commercial consultation or get a property valuation.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

Have questions about buying, selling, or leasing commercial property or land in East Georgia? Reach out to Ashley Goodroe today for expert guidance, personalized service, and proven results in your real estate journey.

Follow Me on Instagram